Client Ratings (Score/Number of Best in Class Awards )
Plan Size Resp Participant Services ( 13 possible)
Micro <$5MM
94.4% B+
88.4% 0
Small $5MM–$50MM
4.2% NOT QUALIFIED
Mid >$50MM–$200MM
1.4% NOT QUALIFIED
Large >$200MM–$1B 0.0% NOT QUALIFIED
Mega >$1B 0.0% NOT QUALIFIED
Highest-Rated Areas of Service
Participant services
1 Participant statements
2 Communication materials
3 Participant call centers
Respondent Plan Types
401(k)
94.4% Profit Sharing
403(b) single
4.2% Money Purch
403(b) multi 0.0% ESOP
Recommendation Likelihood
Extremely likely
62.0%
Moderately/slightly
29.6%
Neutral
7.0%
Recommend against
1.4%
Client Tenure
More than seven years
19.2%
Three to seven years
20.5%
Less than three years
60.3%
Mutual of Omaha
Sponsor Services ( 10 possible)
B+
88.5% 0
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
19.4% NQDC
1.4% SEP/SIMPLE
0.0% 457
Top 4 Industries Represented
1 Health Care (for profit)
2 Financial Services
3 Health Care (nonprofit)
4 Accounting/CPA Firm
Respondent Metrics and Plan Design
Average participation rate
78.4%
Clients with auto-enrollment
27.1%
Clients with Roth provision
47.1%
Avg. parts. maximizing match
74.0%
Clients using adviser
44.3%
Clients offer participant advice
47.1%
Plan Investments
Average expense ratio < 0.75%
35.7%
Clients using non-mutual funds
74.5%
Clients with written IPS
21.3%
0.0%
0.0%
0.0%
71 Responses (% of total plans not available)
Sponsor services
1 Staff consistency
2 Legislative/Regulatory updates
3 Form 5500 processing
9.6%
8.2%
6.8%
5.5%
Client Ratings (Score/Number of Best in Class Awards )
Plan Size Resp Participant Services ( 13 possible)
Micro <$5MM
48.8% B
84.1% 0
Small $5MM–$50MM
23.3% NOT QUALIFIED
Mid >$50MM–$200MM
18.6% NOT QUALIFIED
Large >$200MM–$1B
2.3% NOT QUALIFIED
Mega >$1B
7.0% NOT QUALIFIED
Highest-Rated Areas of Service
Participant services
1 Range of inv options
2 Onsite meetings
3 Enrollment assistance
Respondent Plan Types
401(k)
58.1% Profit Sharing
403(b) single
9.3% Money Purch
403(b) multi 0.0% ESOP
Recommendation Likelihood
Extremely likely
41.8%
Moderately/slightly
44.2%
Neutral
7.0%
Recommend against
7.0%
Client Tenure
More than seven years
72.1%
Three to seven years
16.3%
Less than three years
11.6%
Nationwide Financial
Sponsor Services ( 10 possible)
B
83.9% 0
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
NOT QUALIFIED
Sponsor services
1 Plan design flexibility
2 Sponsor Web site and tools
3 Staff consistency
14.0% NQDC
2.3% SEP/SIMPLE
0.0% 457
2.3%
0.0%
37.2%
Top 4 Industries Represented
1 Gov't: City/Municipal
2 Accounting/CPA Firm
3 Gov't: County/State/Fed
4 Real Estate: Mgt/Inv/Dev
Respondent Metrics and Plan Design
Average participation rate
63.1%
Clients with auto-enrollment
11.9%
Clients with Roth provision
33.3%
Avg. parts. maximizing match
67.9%
Clients using adviser
50.0%
Clients offer participant advice
57.1%
Plan Investments
Average expense ratio < 0.75%
44.8%
Clients using non-mutual funds
75.0%
Clients with written IPS
69.7%
43 Responses (0.1% of total plans)
23.3%
16.3%
14.0%
7.0%
Client Ratings (Score/Number of Best in Class Awards )
Plan Size Resp Participant Services ( 13 possible)
Micro <$5MM
32.5% A
94.2%
5
Small $5MM–$50MM
26.3% A-
90.2%
1
Mid >$50MM–$200MM
28.7% B
86.6%
1
Large >$200MM–$1B
12.5% B-
82.8% 0
Mega >$1B 0.0% NOT QUALIFIED
Highest-Rated Areas of Service
Participant services
1 Participant call centers
2 Retiree services/Payments
3 Loan/ Withdrawal processing
Respondent Plan Types
401(k)
96.2% Profit Sharing
403(b) single 0.0% Money Purch
403(b) multi 0.0% ESOP
Recommendation Likelihood
Extremely likely
60.0%
Moderately/slightly
35.0%
Neutral
5.0%
Recommend against 0.0%
Client Tenure
More than seven years
41.8%
Three to seven years
44.3%
Less than three years
13.9%
New York Life Retirement Plan Services
Sponsor Services ( 10 possible)
A
95.7%
6
B+
89.8% 0
B+
88.1% 0
B+
87.4% 0
NOT QUALIFIED
Sponsor services
1 Regulatory updates
2 Industry knowledge
3 Form 5500 processing
13.9% NQDC
3.8% SEP/SIMPLE
3.8% 457
19.0%
1.3%
6.3%
Top 4 Industries Represented
1 Manufacturing/Consumer
2 Building/Construction
3 Financial Services
4 Auto Dealerships/Svc
Respondent Metrics and Plan Design
Average participation rate
71.8%
Clients with auto-enrollment
51.3%
Clients with Roth provision
30.8%
Avg. parts. maximizing match
72.8%
Clients using adviser
51.3%
Clients offer participant advice
61.5%
Plan Investments
Average expense ratio < 0.75%
48.9%
Clients using non-mutual funds
46.4%
Clients with written IPS
69.5%
80 Responses ( 4.6% of total plans)
12.7%
8.9%
7.6%
6.3%